Which Beans Are The Most Keto
Honestly, you can technically eat *any* bean when youre taking part in the keto diet. But if you want to spread out your carbs throughout several meals instead of eating them all in one cup of black beans , heres the deal.
The only beans that are super keto-friendly are green beans and black soybeans, explains Gans. What makes them so special? Well, while they have roughly the same nutritional value as any other type of beans, green beans and black soybeans are particularly low in carbs: A 1/2 cup of black soybeans provides only eight grams of carbs, 11 grams of protein, seven grams of fiber, and six grams total of fat, Gans notes. *This* is what makes them “keto-friendly,” per se.
The Problem With Beans On Keto
So, with everything that beans have going for them, why are they not part of a keto diet?
While beans are versatile, convenient, nutritious, inexpensive and delicious, their high carb count can make them tough to fit into a low-carb keto diet. Eating too many beans can even pull you out of ketosis. Eating the wrong kinds of beans can also cause your body to start burning sugar instead of fat again.
So how many carbohydrates are in beans? It depends on the type.
Carb counts for one cup of cooked beans:
- Pinto beans
- Black beans
A 1-cup serving of these beans can use up your entire days worth of carbohydrates. When integrating these beans, it’s best to use at most a half-cup serving to preserve available carbs for later in the day.
Some beans may be acceptable on a keto diet because they have fiber and other constituents that lower the amount of carbohydrates the beans actually provide to your body.
Nutrition experts categorize carbohydrates in terms of total carbs and net carbs. Total carbs include all of the different types of carbohydrates in a meal, including indigestible fiber, while net carbs include only the carbohydrates your body can absorb and convert into glucose. For example, a bean that contains 30 grams of total carbohydrates and 7 grams of fiber provides only 23 grams of net carbohydrates .
What Are Some Good Bean Substitutes
Now that you have all the information you need on beans and their relationship to the keto diet, you might be wondering how you can work other low-carb, similarly-textured foods into your everyday eats and meal prep. Here are some great go-to options, according to Sheth.
- Mushrooms. Because of their textured and earth-y taste, chopped mushrooms are a great substitute for any bean-centered meals if youre looking for a swappable option.
- Eggplant.Consider other low-carb vegetables as a swap for beans, says Sheth. She recommends changing out carb-heavy options like hummus for eggplant-based dips like babaganoush.
- Peanuts. Yep, boiled peanuts are legumes, and they can totally be a go-to if youre looking for a bean substitute. Why? They are low in carbs and can provide a similar texture to dishes, says Sheth.
- Avocado. Looking for a high-fat, low-carb substitute for your favorite beans? Avocados or dips like guacamole are a flavorful and easy-to-incorporate option, Sheth says.
- Ground meat. High-protein, lean ground meats are also a flavorful and filling substitute for beans, if youre not on a vegetarian or vegan diet.
The bottom line: Beans can totally be part of a keto diet if you consume low-carb beans, like green beans and black soy beans, and keep track of your portions.
Recommended Reading: Keto Cause High Blood Pressure
Because Its Hard To Follow Keto Can Lead To Yo
Rapid, significant weight loss is a common side effect of the keto diet because of the water losses that occur as carbohydrate stores are depleted, says Clark. In a study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, obese men following a modified version of the ketogenic diet, with high protein and low carbs, lost about 14 pounds in one month, compared with the control group, which lost about 10 pounds on a high-protein, medium-carb diet.
Jalali says people following the diet have the best chance of keeping the weight off if they stay on it long term. And thats not always easy to accomplish. The weight may come back if you go back to your regular eating habits. And regaining weight may lead to other negative effects. Chronic yo-yo dieting appears to increase abdominal fat accumulation and diabetes risk, notes Clark.
Studies have shown that the ability to stick to a diet is more important for long-term success than the type of diet thats followed, says Yawitz. Keto is incredibly restrictive and is particularly tough for those who have frequent social engagements or are prone to carb cravings. The Mediterranean diet allows you to eat carbs, like as many fruits and veggies as you want, along with whole grains. Not to mention, the Mediterranean diet has been linked to a number of other health benefits, including a lower risk of Alzheimers and Parkinsons disease, certain types of cancer, and heart disease, according to the Mayo Clinic.
Health Benefits Of Chickpeas
Aside from being relatively high in fiber and a good source and a complete protein, especially for those who are vegan or vegetarian, what other health benefits do chickpeas offer?
Eating chickpeas may help prevent or offset the development and progression of various chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease, heart disease, and type 2 diabetes. 2
Chickpeas are also rich in:
- Vitamin C
I should also note that chickpeas are high in phytic acid, which may prevent the absorption of minerals, which makes it almost counterproductive.3
While chickpeas do not cause a significant rise in insulin levels and may aid individuals attempting to lose weight, if your goal is to get in and maintain a metabolic state of ketosis, it’s not the best use of carbs.
However, those on a low carb diet may find that they can fit a small amount since their carb limit has a little more flexibility.
Also Check: Will Keto Raise Blood Pressure
How Do I Prevent Beans From Causing Gas
Beans contain a certain type of natural sugar that humans cant digest,therefore it is expelled in the form of gas leading to o an embarrassingflatulence problem. Soaking your beans well before cooking removesmost of the sugar.
Another method that reduces gas production is by changing the waterseveral times during the soaking and cooking process. Always rinse canned beans like black beansand kidney beans, this not only removes the gas-causing sugar but also thesodium.
Another helpful way to de-gas your baked beans and prevent flatulence is to add a potato while cooking and a couple of pinches of baking soda.
Here’s Why Beans Are Actually One Of The Smartest Foods You Can Eat On A Low
Beans are an excellent , but if you’ve assumed you can’t have them on a low-carb diet, think again. While it’s true that beans are high in carbohydrates, “along with that comes fiber mostly soluble fiber, which can help lower cholesterol and important vitamins and minerals like folate, potassium, iron, and zinc,” Kris Sollid, RD, senior director of nutrition communications at the International Food Information Council Foundation, told POPSUGAR.
If you’re familiar with a low-carb diet, you know that fiber reduces your net carbs and can help you stay within your desired range. “Just because beans contain carbohydrates, that doesn’t mean they can’t be eaten as part of a lower carbohydrate diet,” Kris said. “For example, a half cup serving of canned low-sodium black beans contains about 20 grams of carbohydrate, almost 9 of which are fiber, reducing the net carbs to only 11 grams.” This number should fit well within any low-carb plan.
You’ll also do your body good by adding some fiber to your plate, Kris explained. A low-carb diet can shortchange your body on fiber if you cut back on portions of fruits, whole grains, and starchy vegetables in order to stay on track and fiber is good for digestion, helps you feel full after meals, and may help ward off certain types of cancer. “If you follow a low-carb eating plan, beans are a good choice to help you reach your daily fiber needs,” she said.
Recommended Reading: Is Fairlife Keto Friendly
Serious Muscle Loss Is A Possible Side Effect Of Keto
Muscle loss on the ketogenic diet is an ongoing area of research, says Edwina Clark, RD, a dietitian in private practice in San Francisco. Small studies suggest that people on the ketogenic diet lose muscle even when they continue resistance training. This may be related to the fact that protein alone is less effective for muscle building than protein and carbohydrates together after exercise. Meanwhile, according to Sports, people following the keto diet for three months lost about the same amount of body fat and had about the same muscle mass changes as people following normal diets. Yet the folks on keto did lose more leg muscle.
Loss of muscle mass as we age has a number of serious consequences, notes Clark. Muscle is metabolically active and helps boost daily energy expenditure and mitigate age-related weight gain. Losing muscle mass can also decrease functional strength and heighten the risk of falls, notes Clark. Falls are the top cause of death from injury in older populations, according to the Institute of Medicine Division of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention.
Because Keto Severely Limits Carbs You May Develop Nutrient Deficiencies
When carbohydrate intake is low, fiber consumption tends to be low, too. This doesnt come as a surprise when you consider fruits, whole grains, and starchy vegetables are decreased in your diet, says Asche. This can lead to one especially uncomfortable side effect .
Another possible nutrient deficiency: potassium, a mineral important for both electrolyte balance and blood pressure control, notes MedlinePlus. Inadequate intake of potassium is likely when consumption of fruits and starchy vegetables are decreased, says Asche. She recommends adding lower-carb to the diet, including avocado and spinach as well as lower-carb sources of fiber, such as chia seeds and flaxseed .
RELATED: 10 Quick and Easy Keto Snacks
Read Also: Will Keto Raise Blood Pressure
Carbs In Black Beans: Are They Keto
When it comes to net carbs, black beans are surprisingly similar to white potatoes.
Every ½-cup serving of black beans comes with ~13 grams of net carbs. In other words, they are not keto-friendly.
While restricting carbs, it is best to replace black beans with keto-friendly beans or make beanless keto recipes instead.
Bowel Problems Such As Constipation Are Also Common On Keto
Lets talk about a keto side effect that may not be so sexy: constipation. Many of the richest sources of fiber, like beans, fruit, and whole grains are restricted on the ketogenic diet, says Clark. As a result, ketogenic eaters miss out on the benefits of fiber-rich diet such as regular laxation and microbiome support. The microbiome has been implicated in everything from immune function to mental health. Indeed, in a long-term study in t he Journal of Pediatrics in April 2015, constipation was noted as a very common side effect in children receiving ketogenic diets for epilepsy treatment.
In addition to constipation, diarrhea can crop up as a side effect of the keto diet especially in the first few weeks of following it. Some people have difficulty digesting large amounts of dietary fat, which can lead to greasy diarrhea, notes Yawitz.
Also Check: Is Sugar Free Jello Keto Friendly
Throw Some Salmon On The Grill For A Heart
Summer barbecue season is here, and thats good news for fans of the ketogenic diet. Why? Because so many keto-friendly foods are also barbecue staples. Think: bunless burgers, grilled fish, and veggie-loaded sides.
That means if youre on the ketogenic diet or are just trying to eat low-carb, you dont have to miss out on any of the barbecue fun.
Most of the protein-rich meats and poultry served at barbecues will keep you compliant to the keto diet but you do want to be cautious with marinades and sauces, as some may have sugar and other carbohydrate-containing ingredients, says Kristen Smith, RD, a spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics who is based in Atlanta.
You can also enjoy side dishes too, especially if you make some strategic swaps. Smith offers some examples: Some traditional barbecue sides made with potatoes can be made with cauliflower instead, and you can make a salad or other side dish with dark, leafy green vegetables to stick with your keto plan.
Are Baked Beans A Good Carb
One cup of canned baked beans has a whopping 54 grams of carbs. That could be your whole carb budget for one meal. You can still enjoy them and you should, since they also give you protein and fiber. However, limit yourself to a half-cup serving.
Recommended Reading: Carbs In Corn On The Cob Atkins
Overview Of Carbs In Common Bean Varieties
For your convenience, weve included the following table with the carb info for the beans we looked at so far:
Note: All information in this table is for a ½ cup of boiled, drained beans, without salt.
In general, there are hundreds of varieties of edible beans, and most of them are not keto-friendly. When in doubt, make sure to double-check the label and calculate the net carbs yourself.
The same principles apply to the many varieties of lentils as well.
Beans: The Musical Fruit
If you’re not used to eating a lot of beans or other foods rich in fiber, you may experience higher levels of gas and bloating when you first start eating them regularly. Fortunately, most people will notice that their gastrointestinal functioning returns to normal within a few weeks once their bodies gets used to the added fiber, according to the Cleveland Clinic.
To help minimize these problems, Mayo Clinic recommends preparing beans from scratch by soaking them, then throwing away the soaking liquid and cooking them in a fresh pot of water. This can help rid the water of some of the indigestible carbohydrates that produce gas.
Read more:The Side Effects of Beans
If you prefer canned beans, that’s fine too. The canning process breaks down some of those same indigestible carbohydrates, reports the Mayo Clinic. Whether you use canned or dried beans, always cook them until they’re tender this makes them easier to digest.
Taking a digestive aid, such as Beano, may be helpful for some people, as well. Anytime you add fiber to your diet like the generous amounts you’ll get from beans be sure to drink plenty of water to avoid cramping and discomfort, suggests Spritzler.
Don’t Miss: Can You Eat Fried Food On Keto
What Everyone Should Do Before They Attempt The Keto Diet
The bottom line? If youre thinking about trying the ketogenic diet, run it by your doctor first regardless of any preexisting health conditions. And consult a registered dietitian nutritionist to find a nutrition professional who can work with you to create a meal plan you can stick to. People with kidney disease or a history of disordered eating should avoid the diet, and people with type 1 diabetes may want to avoid it, as well. If you have risk factors for heart disease, youll want to speak with your doctor before considering the diet.
How To Make Skillet Green Beans:
Also Check: Cremora Creamer Side Effects
The Carb Counts Of Various Bean Types
If youre looking for a little bit more info on bean types and their various carb counts according to the USDA database, see below. Each of these nutritional values are determined based on half cup measurements.
- Black beans: 20 grams of carbs
- Greens beans: 4 grams of carbs
- Black soybeans: 8 grams of carbs
- Lentils: 18 grams of carbs
- Chickpeas: 25 grams of carbs
- Kidney beans: 20 grams of carbs
- Lima beans: 19 grams of carbs
Why Beans Are Important To Health And Weight Loss
Beans provide a wealth of nutrients including fiber and protein, both strongly associated with satiety and weight management. A cup of black, pinto or garbanzo beans provide approximately 15 grams of protein and between 12 and 16 grams of fiber, according to the U.S. Department of Agricultural Research Service .
Read more:Does Eating Beans Help You Lose Weight?
You’ll also get high amounts of B vitamins like folate and thiamine in a servings of beans. The B vitamins help your body release energy from food, and folate works with B-12 to manufacture red blood cells, according to the National Institute on Aging. Black beans, pinto beans and chickpeas are also excellent sources of minerals such as iron, magnesium, potassium and manganese.
Also Check: Is Natural Bliss Creamer Keto-friendly
An Introduction To Beans
Beans are one of the oldest and most common ingredients in history.
As reviewed by the University of North Dakota, adding beans to your diet may reduce the risk factors for heart disease, diabetes and cancer while being relatively special-diet safe with a gluten free status .
Beans also contain several vitamins and minerals such as:
- Vitamin A
Granted, that doesnt mean beans will agree with everyone or any diet strategy.
White kidney beans and pinto beans have been found to be the largest offenders, with insanely high-calorie counts for even just a cup of beans.
Beans can also be a source of digestive problems due to inflammation caused by enzymes. Though subject-ability occurs on a rare case-by-case basis and can dissipate over time .